As the days pass by after the Delhi high court made its decision on section 377 about decriminalizing LGBTs, there have been oodles of reactions floating about the issue by people from various strata of society. Mr. Moily who lit the fire by arousing the inhumane characteristic of 149 year old law, now is not ready to speak a single word about the same issue. I guess only the CPI(M) made its comments about this whereas the other parties preferred to stay mum. Where are the so called young leaders of congress who should have been the ones to speak their minds about such a taboo in our country? But, the answer is ’no’. No one came to support or rather discuss the sensitivities of the issue. Instead, we still want to continue the same old law made by the Britishers during their regime in India. Sometimes we become too hypocritical. We sometimes don’t agree upon any law made by them and this time as it is a sheer blot on our so called culture and tradition we aren’t ready to fathom. Is it really a blot on our culture? It is however a personal choice or ones genes which decide ones sexual orientation. We are noone to decide it or promote it. But, 'against our culture' is what makes me ponder about.
The question keeps arising ‘n’ number of times in my mind.
So, as it is being said that the benevolence portrayed by Justice Shah (if I’m correct) actually will appreciate more people to indulge in this and eventually loose their character according to our culture. Our culture doesn’t support homosexuality and it is actually the culture of the west, as said by the ‘Mahan gurus’. Is it really so? Is the famous Manu Smriti not the part of Indian scripture? What about the world recognized Sanskrit literature written by Indian scholar Mallanaga Vatsyana? Is this not the part of our culture? They have mentioned about LGBTs long time ago. What about the portrayal of two apsaras at the Khajuraho temple or the Ajantas? Does it fall under the category ‘culture’? I am really confused of what our culture really suggests. I have been hearing stories from our culture where there is clear mention of homosexuals. It is the Indian belief that a eunuch has supernatural powers and they are always part of any festive occasion. Is this Indian culture? But, we still will disagree with the fact that we didn’t imbibe this from west and the case is genetic and not a brain created whim. Why were the voices curbed when the people from Ram Sena were involved in abusing and beating women in public at Bangalore? This indeed is part and parcel of our culture. The world’s largest democracy, as we would like to call ourselves still distinguishes amongst its citizens on the basis of their sex. But, whenever genuine concerns are involved, we always like to hide behind our culture and tradition. Our (Indian) culture also states respect of each others religion. It also states respect of women in society. Also,’athithi devo bhava’ is a very important part of our culture. But, relentless news of molestation and ill-treatment with foreign guests is the regular part of our society. Do we really follow even the pronounced principles in our culture? Are we responsible enough to accept the truth and stop giving unnecessary explanations? The answer is of course not. Why would we compromise on our culture and traditions? Those so called culture chauvinist doesn’t understand the meaning of culture in real sense. It is social liberalisation i.e. to accept each other irrespective of its caste, creed, sex and even the Indian constitution under 42nd amendment has approved of the fact. If am correct we still haven’t allowed gay marriages. It is just decriminalization so that they can have their identity as well as have aid to medical facilities’ without fearing the law. Won’t this solve most of our problem? But, we still choose to differentiate and treat LGBTs as a subject of caricature, when most of the then British colonies as well as Britain itself has amendments regarding LGBT law. Its not only the matter of homosexuals the agitators have always bludgeoned during many such controvertial cases;the one I remember being the Shah Bano case.
Let us take a wider perspective to the issue. There have been numerous world examples as well as philosophers whose work proves the existence of this community is normal and genetic. It is said that the genius, Leonardo da Vinci, was homosexual. We all are aware of Da Vinci and his most famous painting, The Mona Lisa. Dan Brown states "The Mona Lisa's status as the most famous piece of art in the world has nothing to do with the painting itself but rather because Leonardo da Vinci claimed she was his finest accomplishment. He carried it with him whenever he traveled and stated he found it hard to part with his most sublime expression of female beauty". How could this be? Mona Lisa certainly is not particularly beautiful by today's standards and most likely wasn't in Da Vinci's time either. It also is not a great work of art. There had to be a profound but hidden message that Da Vinci held dear and wanted to convey to those who could recognize and appreciate it. Possibly he thought of it as his most meaningful legacy. What could it be and whom did he want to convey it to?
According to Brown, a computerized analysis of the Mona Lisa and Da Vinci's self-portraits show a congruency in their faces. "His Mona Lisa is neither male nor female. It carries a subtle message of androgyny. It is a fusing of both." Brown also points out that Amon is the Egyptian god of masculine fertility and Isis is the Egyptian goddess of female fertility who was once called l'isa. Convert Amon to Mona and add Lisa and you have the name of the painting. "Gentlemen, not only does the face of Mona Lisa look androgynous, but her name is an anagram of the divine union of male and female."
Why was this so important to Da Vinci and to this discussion? I believe he was communicating his belief that a homosexual is a truly exceptional person due to having the fusion of both male and female in the same body. It is not a defect, but a particular form of perfection. I believe he wanted to communicate this not to everyone, but to other homosexuals who suffered from believing they were defective. Perhaps they would recognize this subtle message and it would help, long after he was gone.
The information world is crammed with such examples; but, Indian culture is different. But, it is said, this all is not the part of our culture. We are unique and the uniqueness is showcased at every point. I wish I was smart enough to understand what our “gurus” want to convey through our culture and understand our multifaceted modern culture?
The question keeps arising ‘n’ number of times in my mind.
So, as it is being said that the benevolence portrayed by Justice Shah (if I’m correct) actually will appreciate more people to indulge in this and eventually loose their character according to our culture. Our culture doesn’t support homosexuality and it is actually the culture of the west, as said by the ‘Mahan gurus’. Is it really so? Is the famous Manu Smriti not the part of Indian scripture? What about the world recognized Sanskrit literature written by Indian scholar Mallanaga Vatsyana? Is this not the part of our culture? They have mentioned about LGBTs long time ago. What about the portrayal of two apsaras at the Khajuraho temple or the Ajantas? Does it fall under the category ‘culture’? I am really confused of what our culture really suggests. I have been hearing stories from our culture where there is clear mention of homosexuals. It is the Indian belief that a eunuch has supernatural powers and they are always part of any festive occasion. Is this Indian culture? But, we still will disagree with the fact that we didn’t imbibe this from west and the case is genetic and not a brain created whim. Why were the voices curbed when the people from Ram Sena were involved in abusing and beating women in public at Bangalore? This indeed is part and parcel of our culture. The world’s largest democracy, as we would like to call ourselves still distinguishes amongst its citizens on the basis of their sex. But, whenever genuine concerns are involved, we always like to hide behind our culture and tradition. Our (Indian) culture also states respect of each others religion. It also states respect of women in society. Also,’athithi devo bhava’ is a very important part of our culture. But, relentless news of molestation and ill-treatment with foreign guests is the regular part of our society. Do we really follow even the pronounced principles in our culture? Are we responsible enough to accept the truth and stop giving unnecessary explanations? The answer is of course not. Why would we compromise on our culture and traditions? Those so called culture chauvinist doesn’t understand the meaning of culture in real sense. It is social liberalisation i.e. to accept each other irrespective of its caste, creed, sex and even the Indian constitution under 42nd amendment has approved of the fact. If am correct we still haven’t allowed gay marriages. It is just decriminalization so that they can have their identity as well as have aid to medical facilities’ without fearing the law. Won’t this solve most of our problem? But, we still choose to differentiate and treat LGBTs as a subject of caricature, when most of the then British colonies as well as Britain itself has amendments regarding LGBT law. Its not only the matter of homosexuals the agitators have always bludgeoned during many such controvertial cases;the one I remember being the Shah Bano case.
Let us take a wider perspective to the issue. There have been numerous world examples as well as philosophers whose work proves the existence of this community is normal and genetic. It is said that the genius, Leonardo da Vinci, was homosexual. We all are aware of Da Vinci and his most famous painting, The Mona Lisa. Dan Brown states "The Mona Lisa's status as the most famous piece of art in the world has nothing to do with the painting itself but rather because Leonardo da Vinci claimed she was his finest accomplishment. He carried it with him whenever he traveled and stated he found it hard to part with his most sublime expression of female beauty". How could this be? Mona Lisa certainly is not particularly beautiful by today's standards and most likely wasn't in Da Vinci's time either. It also is not a great work of art. There had to be a profound but hidden message that Da Vinci held dear and wanted to convey to those who could recognize and appreciate it. Possibly he thought of it as his most meaningful legacy. What could it be and whom did he want to convey it to?
According to Brown, a computerized analysis of the Mona Lisa and Da Vinci's self-portraits show a congruency in their faces. "His Mona Lisa is neither male nor female. It carries a subtle message of androgyny. It is a fusing of both." Brown also points out that Amon is the Egyptian god of masculine fertility and Isis is the Egyptian goddess of female fertility who was once called l'isa. Convert Amon to Mona and add Lisa and you have the name of the painting. "Gentlemen, not only does the face of Mona Lisa look androgynous, but her name is an anagram of the divine union of male and female."
Why was this so important to Da Vinci and to this discussion? I believe he was communicating his belief that a homosexual is a truly exceptional person due to having the fusion of both male and female in the same body. It is not a defect, but a particular form of perfection. I believe he wanted to communicate this not to everyone, but to other homosexuals who suffered from believing they were defective. Perhaps they would recognize this subtle message and it would help, long after he was gone.
The information world is crammed with such examples; but, Indian culture is different. But, it is said, this all is not the part of our culture. We are unique and the uniqueness is showcased at every point. I wish I was smart enough to understand what our “gurus” want to convey through our culture and understand our multifaceted modern culture?
good.
ReplyDeletehitesh was here... :)
ReplyDeletei suggest that u invite opinions from more people on ur blog posts... put it on orkut or something atleast till people know n remember that u hav a blog.. it takes little time. but ur articles r well informed n gud enough to make a fair reading.. u will get good feedback n responses that ll help n motivate in developing ur knowledge in different directions.. more importantly, u ll know how ur thoughts r perceived by a third person.. wil help u in gd(s)n all..
ReplyDeleteGood one...especially the Mona Lisa part makes you give a second thought to your convictions..
ReplyDelete